[time-nuts] femtosecond jitter anyone?
jdb at lartmaker.nl
Fri Apr 24 12:08:34 UTC 2009
[Another late reply -- Easter and taxes got in the way]
At 09:59 -0400 09-04-2009, Chris Mack / N1SKY wrote:
>Imagine this: if you were the mastering engineer for Elvis 50 years
>ago, and if today's digital technology was available back then, would
>you want to archive the King's record inside Iron Mountain on MP3?
>Not really, you would want the most resolution possible for the re-
>release onto 32-bit 384kHz whiz-bang chip media in the future. And
>cumulative error for successive re-releases over the decade for
>frequency drift and re-archival is maybe another concern.
What cumulative errors are going to impact digital->digital transfers??
>For example, I am currently using a Rosendahl Nanoclocks (http://
>www.rosendahl-studiotechnik.com/nanoclocks.html) for my house master
>word clock and a $6k Eventide Orville for processing of audio. The
>Eventide used to measure the Nanoclocks at 88200 Hz... now it
>measures 88201 Hz 4 years later... something drifted.... The
>Rosendahl uses normal ambient crystals (although they have trimmer
>caps) and use 74ACT00 logic to drive the distribution outputs. The
>Eventide, I assume uses normal ambient crystals too for the myriad of
>DSPs in it....
(What do you mean by 'ambient crystal'? AT cut with minimal df/dT at
So your Nanoclock drifted relative to your Eventide. Even assuming
that the absolute frequency shift of your converter clock was this
much, that translates to a pitch shift of 0.02 cent. Find me *anyone*
who can hear that in an ABX test. For that matter, try finding a
string instrument that stays within 0.02 cent of its tuning after a
minute or two of playing.
>I believe Mr. Lavry for his 127dB ADC uses an OCXO which helps
>achieve the specs. http://www.lavryengineering.com/
The fact that one good converter uses an OCXO doesn't mean that you
have to use an OCXO to build a good converter. The Grimm one
mentioned by Chris C gets by just fine without one, for example.
[plus, all things being equal an ovenized oscillator has higher
Johnson noise than one running at room temperature]
LART. 250 MIPS under one Watt. Free hardware design files.
More information about the time-nuts