[time-nuts] HP 5328 PSU nightmare... Or stupid engineer, you decide...
sar10538 at gmail.com
Fri Sep 11 11:46:01 UTC 2009
I have no experience with this beast but to draw this sort of current
it points to a possible bypass cap short. If there are any dipped
tants in there, there is a high possibility that one or more of them
have gone short. If you have a good 4-wire ohm meter and a kelvin
probe, just check round to see if you can find some that are very low
ohms before you end up un-soldering them. Other than that it's down to
un-soldering off parts of the circuit to see where the big load is.
Logical isolation always seems the most sensible way to isolate
circuits but the number of time this has let me down so I frequently
use a binary chop method and make no 'educated guesses'. A variac
works well to drop the voltage but you may not easily find the fault
on a a switcher this way. At the very least you will always need good
ways to un-solder things.
I'm sure we will all look forward to your input to the group and it
will be interesting to hear in what field of time-nuttiness you work.
2009/9/10 Douglas Wire - PUPCo Studios <contact at pupcostudios.com>:
> Good day everyone and thank you all for hosting this wonderful community
> and allowing me to participate. I have several HP5328 with the “really-
> nice” newer 10811-xxxxx Oscillators in them. I have found while I have
> used the good old gold trace reliable HP instruments all of my life, these
> units have been especially difficult. The first unit the 4500uF
> electrolytic’s went bad and produced essentially a dead short; an easy
> enough repair for me to not only track down in minutes, but it only takes a
> straight bit screwdriver to fix in seconds!
> Now our second unit has been giving me fits and while I would agree 100%
> with one of the posts I saw here about how well HP did not only with their
> schematics, but also the wonderful troubleshooting flow charts usually make
> repairs on any of their old units a breeze. Sadly I have a unit here that
> is giving us fits! It is a PSU issue and not related to the Motherboard or
> any of the cards as I tested it with everything unhooked/ unsoldered and
> still got the same result. It is quite similar to what we see when we get
> an old HP unit that has a fried cap and is darn near creating a short to
> ground, but alas I simply cannot find the problem (I am sure it is starring
> me in the face is and I just can’t see it…) What I am seeing is super
> high current flow through the R1 (I believe, but HP’s every unit I have
> ever serviced had.47Ω resistor, NOT a 22-Ω as is stated in the
> schematic…) that leads to F1. The troubleshooting is complicated by the
> fact that unless I want to smoke that heavy duty, relatively close
> tolerance resistor, I cannot even check voltages anywhere for it will blow
> the fuse or if I put a slow blow to try and catch some measurements in a
> second or two, well that is not very feasible either.
> If I had to guess, I would say it has either a cap that has fried, outside
> chance of a transformer issue, or the way this thing reacts, pretty well an
> effective dead short somewhere, but I will be damned if I can find the
> problem anywhere. I replaced the bad and 4500uF caps as well as the
> rectifier, wondering if part of it had blown with no change in its issues.
> One cannot follow the flow cart to much of anything other than boxes that
> say look for a short, but so many areas one tests even on a perfectly
> working unit come clear down near the zero Ω point even when they are
> operating correctly.
> I apologize if 1) this is not a clear email that anyone can easily
> understand and 2) I almost feel embarrassed to ask anyone for advice from
> their practical experience, for I feel as If I should easily be able to get
> to the bottom of this in a matter of minutes with the wonderful data HP
> provides us all for these old workhorses.
> So if anyone has run into a problem such as this in the past where working
> the flow chart only yields No, No, No -> check for shorts and has any
> advice for how I might logically proceed, or what in fact you have found
> out in dealing with a similar problem, it would be of great help, as we
> need this in-service ASAP, but I guess I just cannot see the forest for the
> tress in front of me or something here… Any advise, suggestions would be
> greatly appreciated.
> I would like to become a more active participant here with all I can
> contribute, which hopefully soon should be a lot as I am doing some
> innovative timing and generation processes that I am relatively sure the
> outcome and data from derived from it could be of great benefit to the TIME-
> NUTS userbase here. Thanks and don’t be too hard on me for asking (what to
> me sounds like a stupid amateur question) but I am either too tired to
> reason correctly, or it is just one of those very pesky problems, that
> hopefully someone has identified before and might be able to enlighten us
> over. I am begiinign to wonder if a voltage regulator might be responsible,
> but I am at a loss at the moment and have not had enough sleep to properly
> think this repair through… Thank you again everyone!
> Warm regards,
> Douglas M. Wire, GED, FNA,
> PUPCo Studios, PUPCo Research Group
> time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts at febo.com
> To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts
> and follow the instructions there.
Steve Rooke - ZL3TUV & G8KVD
A man with one clock knows what time it is;
A man with two clocks is never quite sure.
More information about the time-nuts