[time-nuts] My Garmin 18x, Ver 3.50, currently 1 second slow to UTC
jgray at zianet.com
Tue Jan 4 23:29:43 EST 2011
Thanks a lot for comparing firmwares. That hard information helps tremendously.
On Tue, Jan 4, 2011 at 8:46 PM, Kiwi Geoff <geoff36 at gmail.com> wrote:
> Joseph Gray wrote:
>> If I am using the NMEA data (as in the Garmin is the only time
>> source), what firmware is recommended by all those using a GPS18x-LVC?
> I thought I would run some tests for you Joe, using Version 3.0 and 3.2
> Although I myself have run version 3.0 for a number of months (when it
> first came out in 2009) without issues, I take note of what Kasper
> Pedersen wrote about his experience - so I have now loaded version
> 3.2 into my 18x, rather than any newer version (until Garmin fix the
> NMEA latency issue).
> I ran my tests for 2 hours each (7,200 one second samples) with GPS
> sitting on an inside window sill with a very limited view of the sky,
> so my readings should be taken as perhaps worse case rather than from
> a perfect view of the sky. The GPS was using 9 - 10 satellites for the
> fix solution during the test.
> The RF sensitivity of the 18x is much better than the Garmin 18.
> I measured the time of the "START" character ($) of the $GPRMC
> sentence and the "LAST" 0x10 (Linefeed) character, GPS 18x set to
> 4800 Baud.
> Following times are in milliseconds from the leading edge of the 1PPS marker.
> Version 3.00 firmware for Garmin 18x
> START Min = 365
> START Avg = 427 (N = 7200)
> START Max = 499
> LAST Min = 513
> LAST Avg = 576 (N = 7200)
> LAST Max = 648
> Version 3.20 firmware for Garmin 18x
> START Min = 370
> START Avg = 433 (N = 7200)
> START Max = 518
> LAST Min = 519
> LAST Avg = 582 (N = 7200)
> LAST Max= 667
> So if you use Version 3.20 firmware for the 18x, at 4800 baud the NMEA
> RMC sentence will give the time of the current UTC second and will be
> received by an average of 582 ms after the leading edge of the 1PPS
> transition (with a maximum jitter of plus 85 ms / minus 63 ms).
> From what I have said earlier in the thread, and from tests that
> Kasper Pedersen has done, I think we can say that currently version
> 3.2 is the "best" version if you want to use the 18x NMEA timestamps
> to be given early in the second (rather than much later as per version
> 3.3 and 3.5).
> Joe, you can download GPS18xPC_LVC_320.exe from here:
> The above file is identical to the one I downloaded in 2009 from Garmin.
> Hope that helps.
> Regards, Geoff (Christchurch, New Zealand).
> time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts at febo.com
> To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts
> and follow the instructions there.
More information about the time-nuts