[time-nuts] Low-Cost Rubidium Performance
John Ackermann N8UR
jra at febo.com
Thu Feb 9 02:36:06 UTC 2012
As threatened, I've measured stability (out to a trustworthy 10K
seconds) and phase noise of the three popular telecom surplus Rb
standards. I looked at two units of the FE-5680, two units of the
Efratom FRS, and one Datum LPRO. (I have two more LPROs but don't have
the mating connector on hand, and didn't want to solder on all three.)
The Cliff Notes version:
* The units had similar short term stability from 1 to 100 seconds.
* Above 100 seconds, the LPRO was the clear winner. The FE and FRS
split, with one of each being the worst two.
* The FE-5680 phase noise loses big-time, both in noise floor and in the
quantity and amplitude of spurs. That DDS comes with a price.
* The LPRO has the best phase noise floor and cleanest spectrum.
Pretty plots and the underlying data are at
Important note: there's known to be a lot of variability among these
units, so my sample size of one or two each isn't a guarantee that your
unit will perform similarly.
Next step is to do some longer-term stability measurements (out to 100K
seconds). You may see that data in a month or so.
More information about the time-nuts