[time-nuts] HP-105B Battery Replacement?
jn6wfo at gmail.com
Thu Sep 15 14:04:09 EDT 2016
Brooke, I priced Ni-Cds and was not happy with the numbers: a set of 20
D-size cells will cost me ~US$100 by the time I get them delivered. That
plus the 8-pound weight penalty makes replacement Ni-Cd cells
unattractive. (105A = 16 pounds, 105B = 24 pounds including the battery
box and charging circuitry) There is no question that Ni-Cds are the
answer for anyone attempting to restore a 105B for competition in the
neighborhood Concours d'Elegance.
I do appreciate your work on the relative merits of the various Lithium
types. I was afraid the existing charge circuitry in the 105B would not
mate well with Lithium-anything batteries. Having twice set the house
afire through assorted misadventures (thank goodness for smoke alarms
and fire extinguishers), I don't want to try for "Number 3".
On 9/15/2016 9:59 AM, Brooke Clarke wrote:
> Hi Jeremy:
> I'm currently having fun playing with various rechargeable battery
> related stuff which includes Li-Ion cells.
> The cells come in three configurations:
> 1. the raw flat top cell with optional tabs to allow easy soldering
> into a pack,
> 2. cell plus positive button cap which includes a Positive Temperature
> Coefficient (PTC) fuse and an over pressure vent,
> 3. fully protected, like 2, plus circuit that turns off the battery if
> charging and over voltage or loaded and under voltage. On these you
> can feel a wire/ribbon running from positive to negative under the
> shrink wrap and they are slightly longer.
> These configurations are independent of the flavor of Li chemistry.
> To go with any of the above you need a charger specific to the
> particular Li chemistry (the charging voltage is not the same) and if
> a pack you also need a either cells like 3 above or a protection
> circuit for the pack. For optimum performance in addition a tap
> between each virtual cell (made of of parallel cells) so that the
> charge can be balanced and a charger that can do that. This is not
> easy, witness the current recall of the Galaxy Note 7s phones.
> I would just use modern Ni-Cad cells mainly because of the ease of
> charging and maintaining them and use the existing charging circuitry.
> Li chemistry has advantages for portable equipment, but not so much
> for rack mounted equipment.
More information about the time-nuts