[time-nuts] Ultra High Stability Time Base Options for 53132A
Richard (Rick) Karlquist
richard at karlquist.com
Sun Apr 12 19:48:37 EDT 2015
On 4/12/2015 2:22 PM, Magnus Danielson wrote:
> The buffer transistors has not AC-bypass of the emitter resistance, so
> that the DC current becomes large and thus contributes flicker noise.
> The comparator at the bottom isn't doing a beutifull work of squaring
> things up without contributing noise, considering the sine output of the
> Was that it, Rick?
The resolution of page 13 is poor, and it seems to be a bitmap instead
of a vector file. The fuzzy thing in the lower right corner looks
like it might be a comparator. I think this was the smoking gun.
There was a saying by H.L. Menken to the effect that for every
complex problem, there is a simple, obvious, invalid solution.
Squaring up a 10811 with a comparator is a perfect example of this
principle. Non-time-nuts always seem to gravitate to this design.
Of course you're right, any comparator will add jitter to a 10811.
The faster they are, the more jitter they add.
I noticed that the standard 10 MHz oscillator is built with
an ECL line receiver. Another example of Menken's saying.
This is a TERRIBLE oscillator design, but one that would appeal
to the non-initiated. I built one of these oscillators in 1976
at the suggestion of my boss. After seeing how bad it was, I
quietly designed it out and never used it again.
Rick Karlquist N6RK
More information about the time-nuts